Columbia staple Immaculate Consumption closed its doors for the final time today after 25 years of feeding the community. The closure follows the University of South Carolina Development Foundation, a private non-profit that coordinates with USC-Columbia on infrastructure projects, purchased the building at 933-937 Main St. earlier this year.
Hibachi House, the Japanese restaurant that occupies the other half of the building, will close in a couple of days. USC Development Foundation President and CEO Jason Caskey said plans are being finalized for new businesses to occupy the vacancies.
Immaculate Consumption and Hibachi House are the latest South Main landmarks acquired by the Foundation. In 2016, the Foundation purchased two properties on the adjacent 800 block of Main Street, then occupied by Sandy’s Famous Hot Dogs and the S.C. Bookstore.
Sandy’s, which first opened in 1989, announced its closure shortly after the Foundation purchased the property, while the Bookstore remained open until August 2019. Sandy’s was subsequently leased to a Domino’s Pizza before the building was recently demolished. The former bookstore was demolished in 2020 and replaced with a public parking lot. The Foundation purchased the neighboring FedEx in 2022.
Earlier this year, the Foundation reached an agreement with the S.C. Baptist Convention to exchange the midblock property occupied by the Baptist Collegiate Ministry building for the former Sandy’s property and an undisclosed sum of money to support construction of a new three-story mixed-use building. The Baptist Convention has since begun construction, while USC and the Development Foundation have secured control of a large, contiguous portion of the 800 block.
The Foundation also purchased Hunter-Gatherer Brewery & Alehouse and Cool Beans Coffee Co. on the block kitty-corner to the 800 block in 2024. Hunter-Gatherer, which first opened at 900 Main St. in 1995, closed its doors two months after it was purchased and the building was promptly demolished. Cool Beans remains open after nearly 30 years, although this may change soon.
Staff at the mediterranean restaurant Green Olive confirmed to the Policy Council that the Development Foundation had purchased their building and plans to close the restaurant in the coming months. It seems like only a matter of time before Cool Beans meets a similar fate.
Below is a map detailing property ownership in the area:

The Foundation justified many of its initial purchases as “defensive,” arguing they were necessary to prevent undesirable development so close to the heart of campus, such as smoke shops and convenience stores. However, after the Board of Trustees approved USC Next, a ten-year master plan created in collaboration with Boston-based planning and design firm Sasaki, USC shifted its messaging from defensive purchases to campus expansion.
When asked about USC Next projects along South Main, architect and Associate Vice President of Facilities Planning, Design and Construction Derek Gruner said, “Who’s going to do it besides USC? We have to be the catalyst.” USC has a history of advocating against private development of the area.
In 2015, a private real estate developer proposed a new 15-story student apartment complex on a 1.26 acre portion of the 800 block that included Sandy’s and the BCM building. The Alumni Association launched a pressure campaign that successfully halted the project. The Development Foundation started buying up the 800 block one year later.
Government assistance
USC-Columbia and the Development Foundation are not the only parties interested in the development of South Main.
SCDOT completed a $25 million revitalization project along South Main from 2023 through 2025 following years of inflation-related delays. While the most noticeable improvements were aesthetic, including upgraded sidewalks and greenery, the project also addressed underlying infrastructure needs. Utility systems were upgraded to accommodate greater capacity anticipating future area development.
In 2024, the City of Columbia announced the Columbia Town and Gown Advisory Committee to facilitate development collaboration between university officials, the government and the community.
This year, the Board of Trustees moved forward with plans to consolidate roughly 2.5-acres of land on the Cool Beans block owned by USC, the Development Foundation, and the state government for a new mixed-use development—including Cool Beans. The USC-owned James F. Byrnes building on the corner of Sumter St. and College St. will be demolished as part of the project. The Board will likely be presented with plans for the 800 block in the near future.
The Development Foundation has no immediate plans to demolish the building that housed Immaculate Consumption for nearly three decades, but if history is any indicator, it is only a matter of time before the building is demolished for future campus expansion.
Exceeding the mandate
USC-Columbia has experienced significant out-of-state growth in recent years as more northerners discover the joys of the palmetto state, but the increase is nowhere near the levels needed to justify the annual increases in university spending.
USC-Columbia's recurring revenue has increased nearly 150% since receiving tuition mitigation, far outpacing its 18.4% student population growth, 3.7% faculty growth, and approximately 30% cumulative inflation from July 2019 to July 2026.
Since the university has been flush with cash, donors have reasonably determined that they would prefer to send their donations to the development fund. There is nothing wrong with private individuals donating to a charitable organization, but the issue arises when the beneficiary of the Development Foundation (the university) is already one of the biggest employers in the state and receives more taxpayer dollars than most state agencies.
USC-Columbia is a public university, not a real estate development firm, yet the Development Foundation has spent a decade purchasing properties along South Main Street with no stated goal beyond the hope of finding a future purpose.
USC-Columbia and the Development Foundation should identify where the existing campus needs improvement and fix those areas before prioritizing expansion. Additionally, the university should demonstrate a need for expansion before “defensively” purchasing property, icing out small businesses.